Quick answer
A psychiatric second opinion offers a thorough, independent review of depression that hasn’t fully lifted. It doesn’t require leaving your current doctor. For Palmetto Bluff residents, it happens privately by video, with recommendations shared with your prescriber if you wish, and care that can continue in South Carolina or New York.
If you’re in crisis right now: call or text 988 (Suicide & Crisis Lifeline) or call 911.
Key Takeaways

- A second opinion adds perspective; it doesn’t replace your current doctor unless you want it to.
- It’s especially useful when treatment has stalled for months or years.
- The review covers history, diagnosis, medical factors and options.
- Recommendations can go to your current prescriber with your consent.
- Second opinions are a normal part of good medical care.
Why people seek a second opinion
Second opinions are common in medicine, from cancer care to surgery. In psychiatry, they’re just as useful. People seek them when depression hasn’t lifted after years of treatment, when side effects are bothersome, when a diagnosis has never been revisited or simply when they want reassurance that nothing has been missed.
For Palmetto Bluff residents whose care may be split between doctors in different states, a careful outside review can bring everything together.
The research behind persistence
Psychiatric News reported that the majority of participants in NIMH’s STAR*D study reached remission within two treatment steps, and researchers encouraged patients not to give up.1 A Journal of Clinical Psychiatry summary also noted lower odds of remission at later steps.2 That combination is exactly why a careful review before the next step is valuable.

What a second opinion covers
Treatment history
Every medicine, dose, duration, benefit and side effect.
Diagnosis and health
A fresh look at the diagnosis and medical factors.
Clear options
Reasoned recommendations for what to try next.
Keeping your current doctor
A second opinion doesn’t mean leaving your psychiatrist. With your written consent, recommendations can be sent to your current prescriber, who may carry them out. Many doctors welcome another perspective. You can also choose to continue care with Dr. Farkas, or take time to decide. Our general page on second opinion consultations explains more.
Want a fresh, careful look at your treatment?
Book an evaluationHow it works by video
The review happens privately by secure video from home. Plan for a longer first visit. Bring records from past doctors in any state, a pharmacy history and recent bloodwork. A spouse can join with your permission. During the review you’ll need to be in South Carolina or New York.

Gathering records from several states
Residents who split time between homes often have records in more than one place. Request them early, with your signed release. Pharmacy printouts fill gaps when records are hard to get. Our page on reviewing every past medication explains how the history is rebuilt.
What happens after
You’ll receive clear recommendations about diagnosis, medical checks and treatment options, including whether any in-clinic treatment is worth considering. You decide what to do with them. If you continue care, changes are planned carefully, one at a time, around your travel and seasonal schedule.
When to ask for one
Consider a second opinion if you’ve been on the same treatment for a year or more without feeling well, if side effects are bothering you, if your diagnosis has never been revisited or if family has noticed you’re not yourself. The American Psychiatric Association offers patient resources on navigating treatment decisions.3
In a crisis
A second opinion is planned care. If you’re in crisis, call or text 988 or call 911.
Questions a second opinion can answer
- Was my diagnosis right, or could something else be going on?
- Did my past medicines get a fair trial?
- Are there medical or medication factors that were missed?
- What are the most promising next steps for me specifically?
- Is any in-clinic treatment worth considering?
Involving family
A spouse or adult child can join the review with your permission, from anywhere. They often remember details of past treatment and notice changes you might not. Their perspective helps make recommendations more complete and practical for your daily life.
A second opinion for a loved one
Adult children sometimes suggest a second opinion for a parent whose depression has lingered. If you’re the one suggesting it, frame it as gathering more information rather than criticizing current care. Offer to help collect records and to join the first visit, with your parent’s permission. Respect their decision, and keep the door open if they’re not ready yet. Many people come around once they see it as information, not judgment.
Practice address and how to reach us
Visits for Palmetto Bluff residents take place by secure video. The practice’s mailing and business address is below, along with the number to call to schedule.
Dr. Gabriella I. Farkas, MD PhD · Pearl Behavioral Health & Medicine
110 Traders Cross, 1st Floor
Bluffton, SC 29909
Phone: 917-267-9678
Text address for reference: 110 Traders Cross, 1st Floor, Bluffton, SC 29909.
Related care for Palmetto Bluff and nearby communities
The bottom line
A thorough second opinion gives Palmetto Bluff residents an independent review of depression treatment, privately by video. You can keep your current doctor, share recommendations with your consent and plan next steps carefully.
Ready to book a first evaluation by video?
Schedule nowFrequently Asked Questions
Do I have to leave my psychiatrist to get a second opinion?
With your written consent, recommendations can be sent to your current prescriber, who may carry them out. You can also choose to continue care with Dr. Many doctors welcome another perspective on a complex case. Many doctors welcome another perspective on a complex case. You can also choose to continue care with Dr. Farkas.
When should I consider a second opinion?
Consider one if depression hasn’t lifted after a year or more of treatment, if side effects bother you, if your diagnosis has never been revisited or if family notices you’re not yourself. Second opinions are a normal part of good medical care, not a criticism of your doctor. A second opinion is a normal part of good medical care. It is not a criticism of your current doctor.
What should I bring?
Bring records from past doctors in any state, a pharmacy history, a list of every antidepressant you’ve tried with doses and durations if known, current medicines from all doctors and recent bloodwork. Bring what you have, even if it’s incomplete. Bring what you have, even if it is incomplete. Records can be requested later with your permission.
How long does a second opinion take?
Plan for a longer first visit, often 60 to 90 minutes. Sometimes a follow-up is needed after records arrive or tests are done. If you continue care, regular follow-up visits track progress over the following months. Sometimes a follow-up is needed after records arrive. Plan for a longer first visit at a quiet time.
Can a second opinion be done by video?
The review happens privately by secure video from home. You need to be in South Carolina or New York during the visit. A spouse or adult child can join from anywhere with your permission. Records and lab results are shared electronically. A spouse or adult child can join from anywhere with your permission.
Will my current doctor be offended?
Most doctors understand that second opinions are normal, especially for depression that hasn’t fully responded. You can tell your doctor you’re seeking one, and with your permission, recommendations can be shared directly with them afterward. You can tell your doctor you are seeking one. Recommendations can be shared directly with them afterward.
What happens after I get the recommendations?
You can share them with your current doctor, continue care with Dr. If you continue, changes are planned carefully, one at a time, around your travel and seasonal schedule, with progress measured along the way. Changes are planned one at a time around your travel schedule. Progress is measured along the way with short questionnaires.
How We Reviewed This Page
This page draws on sources including Psychiatric News, Journal of Clinical Psychiatry and American Psychiatric Association. It was written by Steven Lockhart and is pending clinical review by Gabriella I. Farkas, MD PhD, a psychiatrist licensed in South Carolina and New York. We review it at least every 180 days.
What’s new: November 2026. Page published. Clinical review by Dr. Farkas pending.
References
- Psychiatric News (American Psychiatric Association). STAR*D results: one-third remit after the first step. 2006;41(8). https://psychiatryonline.org/doi/10.1176/pn.41.8.0042
- Journal of Clinical Psychiatry (Psychiatrist.com). Sequenced Treatment Alternatives to Relieve Depression (STAR*D): summary of findings. https://www.psychiatrist.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/17618_sequenced-treatment-alternatives-relieve-depression.pdf
- American Psychiatric Association. Patients and Families. Accessed November 2026. https://www.psychiatry.org/patients-families



